Brussels: The UN General Assembly on Thursday enjoined Israel and the Palestinians to probe war crimes allegedly committed in Gaza nearly a year ago, a move which the Jewish state said would hurt the quest for Middle East peace.
The 192-member assembly overwhelmingly approved an Arab-sponsored resolution that endorsed a UN report accusing both Israel and the Palestinians of war crimes and possible crimes against humanity during the 22-day Gaza conflict that ended in January.
The move capped a two-day debate on the controversial, 575-page report by a panel led by respected former international prosecutor Richard Goldstone.
The vote was 114 in favour and 18 against, with 44 abstentions. A simple majority was needed for adoption.
Israel, which had strenuously opposed the non-binding resolution and the UN report that it endorsed, voted against it as did its staunchest ally, the United States, along with Australia and a few European countries.
A majority of European Union countries, including Britain, France, Sweden and Spain, abstained after failing to secure amendments to the text, including one that would have dropped references to possible Security Council action if the report’s findings are not implemented. Russia also abstained.
Goldstone, a South African Jew, had recommended that Israel and the Islamist movement Hamas that rules Gaza face possible prosecution before the International Criminal Court in The Hague if they fail to conduct credible, independent investigations within six months.
Independent probe
The assembly resolution also called on both Israel and the Palestinian side to conduct, within a period of three months, investigations “that are independent, credible and in conformity with international standards.”
Israel’s deputy UN ambassador Daniel Carmon slammed the resolution as “deeply flawed, one-sided and prejudiced.”
“It disregards Israel’s inherent right to defend its citizens in the face of ongoing terrorist attacks,” he added. “It represents yet another pretext to bash Israel at the UN and is detrimental to any positive diplomatic engagement in the region.”
Prior to the vote, Carmon asked the sponsors to clarify exactly which entity is supposed to conduct the investigation on the Palestinian side: the Palestinian Authority led by Mahmoud Abbas or “the terrorist entity” Hamas.
Explaining his country’s “no” vote, US deputy ambassador Alejandro Wolff stressed that Washington “strongly supports accountability for human rights and humanitarian law violations in relation to the Gaza conflict.”
“Our goal is to achieve genuine accountability in a way that respects internal processes and the ongoing efforts to restart permanent status negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians,” he added.
Yahya Mahmassani, the permanent observer of the 22-member Arab League, welcomed the adoption of the resolution as “a very good result.” “This is a victory for justice and accountability,” he added, saying the Arab sponsors would consider their next step after hopefully receiving a report from UN chief Ban Ki-moon on implementation of the resolution.
A key finding of the Goldstone report was that Israel used disproportionate force in response to repeated rocket attacks by Gaza-based militants and failed to take adequate measures to protect civilians during its Gaza onslaught.
Some 1,400 Palestinians and 13 Israelis were killed during the Israeli military offensive in the tiny coastal Palestinian enclave.
The Palestinian observer to the United Nations, Ryad Mansour, hailed what he called “an important night in the history of the General Assembly and the history of fighting impunity and seeking accountability.”
He highlighted the fact that the resolution directs Ban to report back to the General Assembly on its implementation within three months, with “a view to considering further action, if necessary, by the relevant UN organs and bodies, including by the Security Council.”
